HOW TO: Evaluate a web agency?

by | Feb 15, 2023 | Burning Questions

Table of Contents
The process of choosing a web agency can be complex and challenging. There are numerous factors to consider in order to make an informed decision. This series of questions and answers is designed to guide you through this evaluation process, providing insights on crucial factors and considerations to ensure you make a choice that aligns with your project goals and expectations.

An agency’s competence level, their specialisation, and the energy of the team are key elements to consider. Whether they are SEO or content focused, the quality, speed, and price of their services form a crucial triad that must be balanced to suit your project’s needs. The location of the agency and the choice between freelancers and agencies are other aspects that might significantly impact the project’s success.

An agency’s approach to promoting your website, their familiarity with core tech platforms, and their ability to ensure that you own the developed code are significant factors to consider. The business terms length, their specialisation vs generalisation, and their focus on search or content, are essential in understanding if the agency will be able to cater to your specific needs.

The importance of a learning culture within the agency, their competence level, and the added value they provide, all contribute to their ability to deliver a successful project. Their approach to the project lifecycle, communication, and collaboration with clients are also significant considerations.

It’s important to check their portfolio and look for testimonials from previous clients to understand their track record in delivering successful projects. Consider their approach to maintenance and support after the website launch, their ability to stay updated with the latest trends, and their experience in implementing user-friendly and mobile-responsive design.

The agency’s commitment to website performance optimisation, security, accessibility, and SEO are essential in the modern digital landscape. They should be able to provide examples of successful digital marketing campaigns they have executed.

In summary, these questions and answers provide a comprehensive guide to evaluating a web agency, ensuring that all crucial aspects are considered. The answers are designed to inform your decision-making process, helping you select an agency that will meet your project requirements and deliver a successful outcome.

1. How can you evaluate a web agency for long-term cooperation?

Long-term cooperation with a digtial agency relies on several factors such as their reliability, adaptability, and quality of work. A systematic approach to evaluation should be undertaken. Look into their past projects, testimonials, and their method of communication with clients. This article on Forbes provides useful tips for evaluating a marketing agency.

2. What factors should be considered when evaluating a web agency?

Key considerations include:

  1. Expertise and Experience: Have they worked on similar projects before?
  2. Portfolio: Does their past work align with your expectations?
  3. Reputation: What do their past clients say about them?
  4. Communication: How quickly and effectively do they respond?
  5. Price: Is their pricing competitive and does it offer value for money?

3. Why is team energy important when choosing a web agency?

Team energy reflects the enthusiasm and dedication of the agency’s team towards your project. A team with high energy is likely to be more invested in the success of your project, fostering creativity, productivity, and effective collaboration. A Harvard Business Review article further explains the impact of team energy on productivity.

4. What are the red flags to watch out for when selecting a web agency?

Key red flags include:

  • Poor communication or delayed responses
  • A lack of transparency in their processes
  • Over-promising and under-delivering
  • Outdated portfolio or a lack of relevant experience
  • Negative reviews or feedback from previous clients

5. How should the location of a web agency be taken into account?

While digital technologies have made it possible to work seamlessly with agencies anywhere in the world, location still plays a role in decision-making. Considerations include timezone differences, cultural understanding, language proficiency, and the possibility of face-to-face meetings. Here is an article that discusses the pros and cons of offshoring and nearshoring.

6. What are the advantages and disadvantages of working with freelancers vs. agencies?

Working with freelancers can provide advantages like cost-effectiveness, flexibility, and a personal touch to the projects. However, freelancers might be handling multiple projects, which may affect your project’s attention and pace. On the other hand, agencies typically have a pool of talents, ensuring your project continuity and a broader range of expertise. However, their services might be more expensive. More details can be found in this article.

7. What is the difference between SEO agencies and content agencies?

SEO agencies focus on optimising your website for search engines, improving its visibility on search results, and driving organic traffic. They conduct keyword research, on-page and off-page optimisation, and technical SEO. Conversely, content agencies concentrate on creating valuable content that resonates with your audience. They might provide copywriting, blog posts, whitepapers, social media content, and more. This article provides more information.

8. How do quality, speed, and price interact when evaluating web agencies?

The interaction between quality, speed, and price is often summarised by the project management triangle, where you can only optimise two out of the three. High-quality work delivered quickly will likely be more expensive. On the other hand, low-cost services delivered fast might compromise on quality. It’s important to balance these aspects based on your business needs and budget.

9. Why is it important to consider specialisation vs. generalisation in a web agency?

Specialised agencies offer expertise in a specific area, delivering high-quality work in their niche, while generalist agencies might have a broad knowledge across many areas. The choice between the two depends on your needs. If you require a particular skill or industry expertise, a specialised agency might be preferable. If you need varied services, a generalist agency could be a better fit. This article delves deeper into this matter.

10. What should be the focus when evaluating a web agency: search or content?

The choice between a search-focused agency and a content-focused agency largely depends on your business goals. If your primary goal is to increase website visibility on search engines and drive organic traffic, a search (SEO) agency might be more suitable. If your goal is to engage your audience with valuable content, improve brand loyalty and drive customer action, a content agency would be beneficial. It’s also important to note that content and SEO work hand in hand – high-quality, SEO-optimised content can drive significant traffic to your website.

11. How can you ensure that you own the code developed by a web agency?

Ensuring code ownership is crucial for future modifications and security purposes. This should be clarified in the contract before the project starts, stating that you will have the ownership rights of the code after the project is completed. To know more about this, you may refer to this Forbes article.

12. What are the key considerations when selecting core tech platforms for a web agency?

When selecting tech platforms, consider their functionality, user-friendliness, scalability, compatibility with existing systems, and support services. The platforms should be reliable and capable of meeting your business needs. Also, consider their security features to protect your data.

13. How can a web agency effectively promote your website?

A web agency can promote your website using various strategies, including SEO, content marketing, social media marketing, and pay-per-click advertising. The agency should use data-driven strategies, track the results, and adjust the strategies as needed. For more insights, read this Business 2 Community article.

14. Why is competence level an important factor when choosing a web agency?

The competence level of a web agency determines their ability to deliver high-quality work, meet deadlines, and solve problems that might arise during the project. Agencies with high competence levels can provide innovative solutions and contribute significantly to the success of your project.

15. What are the benefits of having a learning culture in a web agency?

A learning culture encourages continuous improvement and innovation. It ensures the agency stays up-to-date with the latest trends and technologies, which can result in better results for your project. Furthermore, it fosters a growth mindset, improves employee satisfaction, and reduces turnover. This article further elaborates on the importance of a learning culture.

16. What should be considered in terms of business terms length when evaluating a web agency?

The length of business terms should align with your project timeline and long-term goals. Short-term contracts offer flexibility but might involve higher rates. Long-term contracts can foster better collaboration and understanding, but it might be challenging to change providers if you’re unsatisfied with their service.

17. How can you determine if a web agency is a good fit for your project?

You can determine the suitability of a digital agency for your project by evaluating their expertise, portfolio, testimonials, communication style, and pricing. Ensure they have experience in similar projects or your industry. Understand their workflow and project management style to see if it matches your expectations. Compatibility in communication style and values is also vital for a successful partnership. Read this article for more insights.

18. Why is it important to consider the values and communication style of a web agency?

The values of a web agency reflect their work ethic and business conduct. It’s important to align with an agency that upholds values like honesty, transparency, and respect. Their communication style is also critical as it affects project management, problem-solving, and overall collaboration. An agency that communicates effectively can prevent misunderstandings and ensure smooth project execution.

19. How can you assess the added value provided by a web agency?

The added value can be assessed in terms of the unique services they provide, their level of expertise, innovative ideas, industry insights, and commitment to your project’s success. Look for agencies that go beyond the basic services and bring creative solutions, strategies, and invaluable advice to the table.

20. What should be evaluated in terms of the project lifecycle when selecting a web agency?

When evaluating the project lifecycle, consider the agency’s approach to various stages, including planning, design, development, testing, launch, and maintenance. Ensure they have a structured process for each stage, with clear milestones, deliverables, and review mechanisms. Their ability to deliver on time and maintain quality throughout the lifecycle is also crucial.

21. What is the agency’s track record in delivering successful projects?

An agency’s track record can be assessed by reviewing their portfolio, case studies, and client testimonials. Look for evidence of delivered results, such as improved website traffic, increased conversion rates, or achieved business goals. Check their retention rate and repeat business, which indicate client satisfaction.

22. How do they handle project management and ensure timely delivery?

Agencies should have a solid project management process, including a dedicated project manager, regular progress updates, and a system for managing tasks and deadlines. They should also have contingency plans to handle delays or issues that might arise during the project. Effective project management contributes to timely delivery and project success.

23. What is their approach to communication and collaboration with clients?

Web agencies should foster open and transparent communication. They should provide regular updates, be responsive to your queries, and open to your ideas and feedback. Collaboration tools like Slack, Asana, or Trello are often used to streamline communication and manage tasks. A structured communication plan, including scheduled meetings or calls, ensures effective collaboration.

24. How do they handle feedback and incorporate client input during the development process?

A reliable web agency should value your feedback and incorporate it into their work. They should provide clear channels for you to provide feedback and have a process in place to respond to and implement the feedback. Including feedback loops at each stage of the project helps ensure the end product aligns with your expectations.

25. Do they have a portfolio showcasing their previous work and client testimonials?

A web agency’s portfolio gives you a glimpse of their capabilities, style, and quality of work. It shows their experience across different projects and industries. Client testimonials provide insights into their reliability, professionalism, and service quality. Look for case studies that demonstrate their ability to deliver results.

26. What is their process for handling maintenance and ongoing support after the website launch?

Post-launch support is crucial for handling website updates, resolving issues, and ensuring smooth operation. The agency should provide clear information on the scope of their support services, whether they offer maintenance packages, and how they handle requests for changes or additional features.

27. Can they provide examples of websites they have developed in your industry or similar niches?

Examples of websites they’ve developed in your industry or related niches can demonstrate their understanding of your target audience, industry trends, and specific requirements. It shows their ability to deliver a website that fits your business needs and appeals to your audience.

28. How do they stay updated with the latest web design and development trends?

Web agencies should stay abreast of the latest trends to deliver modern, user-friendly websites. They can do this through continuous learning, attending industry events, following relevant publications, and participating in professional networks. Ask them about recent trends they’ve incorporated into their projects to assess their up-to-dateness.

29. What is their approach to user experience (UX) design and ensuring optimal website usability?

The agency should have a user-centric approach, focusing on creating a seamless and enjoyable user experience. They should consider aspects like site navigation, load speed, mobile responsiveness, and user interface design. They should also conduct usability tests to identify and fix any issues that could hinder user experience.

30. Do they have experience in implementing responsive design for mobile-friendly websites?

With increasing mobile internet usage, it’s crucial for websites to be mobile-friendly. The agency should have experience in responsive design, ensuring the website works well and looks good on various screen sizes. They should also consider mobile UX, optimising elements like navigation, buttons, and forms for mobile use.

31. Can they provide insights on website performance optimisation and page loading speed?

Website performance and loading speed significantly impact user experience and SEO. The agency should follow best practices like optimising images, using caching, reducing HTTP requests, and minifying

CSS and JavaScript. They should also use performance testing tools to monitor and improve website speed.

32. How do they ensure website security and protect against potential vulnerabilities?

Website security is critical to protect your data and build trust with users. The agency should adhere to security best practices, such as using secure coding, keeping software updated, implementing SSL, and regular security audits. They should also have a plan to handle potential security incidents.

33. Are they familiar with accessibility standards and guidelines for inclusive website design?

Web accessibility ensures your website can be used by all users, including those with disabilities. The agency should follow accessibility standards and guidelines, such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). This includes providing alt text for images, ensuring sufficient color contrast, and making the website keyboard-friendly.

34. What is their process for search engine optimisation (SEO) and improving website rankings?

SEO is crucial for improving website visibility and attracting organic traffic. The agency should have a comprehensive SEO process, covering keyword research, on-page and off-page SEO, technical SEO, and content marketing. They should also track SEO metrics to measure and improve performance.

35. Can they provide case studies or examples of successful digital marketing campaigns they have executed?

Case studies provide evidence of the agency’s ability to execute successful digital marketing campaigns. They demonstrate their strategic thinking, creativity, and effectiveness in achieving campaign goals. Look for case studies that show clear results, like increased traffic, leads, sales, or brand awareness.

These questions guide the evaluation process when selecting a marketing agency for long-term cooperation. They focus on crucial factors such as the agency’s competence, specialisation, track record, and their approach to project management, communication, and collaboration.

The answers highlight the need for clarity in the agency’s business terms, ensuring code ownership, and selecting appropriate tech platforms. The agency should add value by effectively promoting your website, providing insights, and introducing innovative ideas. It’s essential to align with an agency that upholds values like honesty, transparency, and has a learning culture that encourages continuous improvement and innovation.

The agency’s competence level, experience, and the ability to stay updated with the latest trends are vital. The agency should be able to handle maintenance and provide ongoing support after the website launch. They should also have experience in your industry or similar niches.

Communication and collaboration are key to successful project execution. The agency should handle feedback and incorporate client input during the development process. Their track record can be assessed by reviewing their portfolio, case studies, and client testimonials.

The agency’s approach to the project lifecycle should cover various stages, including planning, design, development, testing, launch, and maintenance. It should ensure user-friendly and mobile-responsive design, website performance optimisation, and security. Familiarity with accessibility standards and guidelines for inclusive website design is also important.

The agency should have a comprehensive process for search engine optimisation (SEO), improving website rankings, and be able to provide case studies or examples of successful digital marketing campaigns. This comprehensive guide ensures you consider all the essential factors to find a web agency that’s a good fit for your project, aligned with your goals, and capable of delivering successful outcomes.

Are Google AI Overviews the Future of Search?

Are Google AI Overviews the Future of Search?

Google AI Overviews mark a major step in search technology. Adopting AI is no longer an option. It's businesses critical to stay ahead. Meanwhile, those struggling with AI implementation risk loosing some market share. The UK AI market is worth over £16.8 billion. It...

Looking for an SEO Agency for the Automotive Sector?

Looking for an SEO Agency for the Automotive Sector?

Follow our guide and you can improve your dealership's digital marketing strategy, here expertise meets execution, and data-driven insights lead to measurable success. We'll compare the dynamic nature of automotive digital marketing to more traditional methods,...

How can Google’s March 2024 Core Update affect your site?

How can Google’s March 2024 Core Update affect your site?

Google announced a significant core update in March 2024 which has since fascinated webmasters, SEO specialists and content creators worldwide. This update - which enhanced search engine results, is designed to cut "unhelpful" information by 40%. A turning point of...

Is Drupal Replatforming worth it?

Is Drupal Replatforming worth it?

We'll look into why businesses might choose Drupal over other CMS platforms. We'll talk about the benefits of Drupal, how to go through the replatforming process, and how to pick the right CMS for your needs. Businesses today are realising that they need a CMS that...

Why is Your WordPress SEO Not Working and How to Fix it?

Why is Your WordPress SEO Not Working and How to Fix it?

Join us as we take a look through these topics and more, offering you a comprehensive guide to increasing your website's visibility and traffic. If you're keen to take your WordPress site to new heights, keep reading for practical advice and expert insights into the...

A Guide to Google Tag Manager

A Guide to Google Tag Manager

With this guide to Google Tag Manager (GTM), we also answer many question for beginners and advanced users alike. Understanding GTM is vital for marketing pros aiming to enhance improve their site performance. Our comprehensive look at GTM presents expert insights and...

HOW TO: Start Using Drupal CMS?

HOW TO: Start Using Drupal CMS?

Discover the Intricacies of Drupal Website Costs and Optimisation We will address the common question that may arise when starting off with Drupal and it's modules, offering solutions and preventative measures to safeguard your site's integrity. Furthermore, we...

HOW TO: Start Optimising Core Web Vitals on Regular Basis?

HOW TO: Start Optimising Core Web Vitals on Regular Basis?

For those looking to refine their approach to website speed optimisation, this article offers a good look at interpreting the results from Page Speed Insights, providing a structured methodology to turn data into decisive action. Moreover, it navigates the...